Bartolotta's Amish Way - Quality Amish Furniture Store Located in Milwaukee, WisconsinQuality Furniture Made the Way It Should Be


9115 West Oklahoma Ave.
Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Google Maps Thumbnailview map to the store

Store Hours:

Tuesday - Saturday: 10am-4pm
Sunday & Monday: Closed

Contact Info:

Phone: 414.541-0122

Now Accepting Appointments!

About Us

The Amish Way promises to provide you & your family quality handcrafted Amish furniture. Tony and Terry Bartolotta owners of the Amish Way, travel to Amish Country 5 times a year to pick-up Amish crafted furniture and accessories. We find that by making the trip ourselves, we insure that we are bringing back exactly what the customer ordered. Also, we are able to see new handcrafted items and designs as they are being created.

Amish Quality

Amish funiture and other items are all hand built by craftsman the same way it has been done for generations, one piece at a time and made to last a lifetime or more. Even the smallest details show the time and effort that is put in to ensure everything is done the right way. The Amish Way!